The best anal lube top picks

The Best Anal Lube For Every Kind of Butt Sex

We had four male testers use 10 top personal lubricants for six weeks, and concluded that Sliquid Silk is the best anal lube for most guys.
We had four male testers use 10 top personal lubricants for six weeks, and concluded that Sliquid Silk is the best anal lube for most guys.
Share on facebook
Share on Facebook
Share on twitter
Tweet on Twitter
Share on pinterest
Pin on Pinterest
Share on facebook
Share on twitter
Share on pinterest
The best anal lube top picks

Top Pick

This all-natural hybrid lube is thick, long-lasting and slippery. It’s easy to wash off with just water, affordable, and never stains sheets.

Sliquid Silk is a thick, super slippery, long-lasting hybrid lubricant for anal sex. It doesn’t contain bad stuff like glycerin or parabens. In fact, all of its ingredients are all-natural and vegan-friendly.

Like other hybrids, Sliquid Silk is mostly water-based lube with a little bit of silicone. This makes it longer-lasting and slicker than water-based lube. According to Sliquid, a bottle of Slick contains “11% to 13%” silicone by volume.

Our testers all liked how long they could go without having to reach for the bottle a second time, and how easy it was to reactivate with a little water or spit.

Even better, when you’re done having sex, it’s fast and easy to wash off your hands and body.

“When it dries, it doesn’t leave that gross, sticky feel on your skin like Astroglide. You don’t need soap to wash it off. Just running my hands under water is enough.” – Tester

Sliquid Silk is compatible with condoms and sex toys made from all different materials—even silicone.

Also Great

This silicone lube feels super-slick, stays wet, and never gets sticky. It moisturizes your skin with vitamin E and aloe, and it’s stain-free. However, it takes a little scrubbing with soap and water to wash off completely.

Gun Oil is one of the top-selling silicone-based lubes, known for its slipperiness and long-lasting lubrication. The vitamin E and aloe vera in Gun Oil leave your skin feeling healthy and supple. Even better, it doesn’t contain parabens or glycerin, two of the most common causes of skin irritation.

Gun Oil gets along well with condoms and adult toys made of porous materials like stainless steel, glass, and hard plastic, but it shouldn’t be used with toys made from silicone or porous materials like TPE or PVC since it degrades their texture.

And like all silicone lubes, it’s a good addition to any trips to the beach or swimming pools since it remains wet in water.

However, after using it, you’ll need to make sure you wash with soap and water to avoid leaving a thin film on things you touch. switches and door knobs. If you are okay with that, you’ll love Gun Oil.

Also Great

This popular all-natural, glycerin-free, paraben-free lube was formulated specifically for anal sex. It has a thicker, sloppier consistency that stays wet longer than other water-based lubes.

Sliquid Sassy is an all-natural water-based lube that’s hypoallergenic, glycerin-free, paraben-free, and vegan-friendly.

You only need a small amount of this and when applying it because it it stays wet for a surprisingly long time. Unlike thinner lubes, Sassy doesn’t drip everywhere after you squeeze it out—it stays exactly where you want it. It gives you the perfect amount of slide without feeling “unnatural”.

Not only is Sassy excellent for anal intercourse, it’s also very good with toys. It’s thick enough to “stick” to the toy’s surface, while still feeling smooth and slippery against your skin.

And when playtime is over, you feel clean because it doesn’t leave a sticky feeling on your skin.

Like all water-based lubes, it is condom-safe and can be used with all kinds of toys.

If you like to keep your lube life simple, Sliquid Sassy is ideal since it can be enjoyed in any hole and with every toy you own.

Also Great

This ultra-concentrated, long-lasting silicone lube offers a unique-yet-effective alternative to desensitizing lubes. Instead of numbing the butt, it relaxes tight butt muscles resulting in pain-free anal sex.

Analyse Me – Silicone is made by Pjur, a German company that’s been for manufacturing premium personal lubricants since 1996.

Pjur markets Analyse Me as a “relaxing” silicone-based lube for anal sex that can be used instead of numbing lubes, which are discouraged by experts.

Unlike other lubes for painful sex, Analyse Me doesn’t contain lidocaine or benzocaine. It contains jojoba and amyris balsamifera, plant extracts that calm sphincter muscles, allowing eager newbies to enjoy anal sex. Most importantly, it really works. Testers were surprised by its effectiveness.

It is super-slippery and has a thin consistency that feels like pre-cum. The thinness also improves sensations during sex by transmitting more of your partner’s body heat and genital contours.

A little goes a long way, and even after lots of thrusting and pumping, it doesn’t dry out.

When it finally dries, it leaves your skin feeling clean and moisturized, but not at all greasy.

“Analyse Me feels like a body fluid and it transmits body heat really well. I loved being able to feel more of my girlfriend’s insides.” – Tester

Also Great

This plant-based cream lube is great for anal and vaginal sex, but can also be used as a massage oil and moisturizer. It feels smooth, but not greasy. It’s non-staining, available in a range of sizes, and very affordable.

The Butters Lube blends cocoa butter and other raw plant-based oils with aloe vera and other natural ingredients into their thick creamy, long-lasting, oil-based lube. When you apply a dab on the skin, the cream melts into an ultra-slick, non-greasy lube that makes anal feel luxurious.

Perfect for anal enthusiasts and anyone looking for lube that’s vegan, wheat-free, gluten-free, fragrance-free, and pH-balanced. Our testers said it feels great slathered on for anal sex and equally good when for vaginal lube or masturbation.

In addition to being great for sex, it can also be used as body moisturizer, hair conditioner, massage oil, shave cream, foot cream, face cleanser, or beard balm since it’s oil-based.

Everything We Recommend

Top Pick

This all-natural hybrid lube is thick, long-lasting and slippery. It’s easy to wash off with just water, affordable, and never stains sheets.

Also Great

This silicone lube feels super-slick, stays wet, and never gets sticky. It moisturizes your skin with vitamin E and aloe, and it’s stain-free. However, it takes a little scrubbing with soap and water to wash off completely.

Also Great

This popular all-natural, glycerin-free, paraben-free lube was formulated specifically for anal sex. It has a thicker, sloppier consistency that stays wet longer than other water-based lubes.

Also Great

This ultra-concentrated, long-lasting silicone lube offers a unique-yet-effective alternative to desensitizing lubes. Instead of numbing the butt, it relaxes tight butt muscles resulting in pain-free anal sex.

Also Great

This plant-based cream lube is great for anal and vaginal sex, but can also be used as a massage oil and moisturizer. It feels smooth, but not greasy. It’s non-staining, available in a range of sizes, and very affordable.

Why buy anal lube?

If you’ve ever enjoyed anal sex or played with butt toys, you understand why it’s important to use anal lube. 

Using lube reduces the friction between the butt hole in question and whatever you want to put into it, and it’s the only way to prevent small tears in the tissue around the anus.

By making everything feel slick, it allows you to relax, feel comfortable, and get the most pleasure from anal sex.

Quality lubes just make butt sex feel better.

Almost any personal lubricant that can be used for vaginal sex can be used for anal sex, but you may prefer one specifically formulated for anal fun. 

Anal lubricants usually have a slightly thicker consistency than regular lubes to provide more slippery comfort and enjoyment.

How we picked and tested

After 19 hours of online research on personal lubricants, reading the advice and recommendations of sex experts, scientists, and doctors, as well as the product descriptions and customer reviews of at online retailers, we created a set of criteria to help us decide which lubes to buy and test for this review.

We purchased 10 different lubes for this six-week product test. Four male testers (including me) with active sex lives integrated them into their sex lives, using them as much as possible. 

Over a month and half of sexual activity, the lubes in this review were put through their paces. Testers used them more than 200 times. They were used for anal sex and vaginal sex with condoms and no condoms. They were also used for quick jack-off sessions and longer sessions with anal toys—including prostate massagers, butt plugs, anal dildos, and vibrators.

To generate data for this test, we got together twice to discuss our first impressions of each lube and share the brief rating and ranking surveys we completed as we used the lubes.

Five important features of anal lubricants

Always check the ingredients

Personal lubricants—like sex toys—aren’t regulated by the FDA or government agencies. Manufacturers sometimes use low-quality, questionable, and downright unsafe ingredients to maximize profits.

Long story short: It’s up to us as consumers to figure out what’s in our sex products.

Dangerous ingredients you should avoid

  • Glycerin –  A sugar that feeds Candida albicans, the fungi that causes yeast infections. Adding glycerin to the rectum can lead to yeast infections.
  • Parabens – Commonly used preservatives that can spark allergic reactions in people with sensitive skin, parabens are also weak endocrine disruptors that have a feminizing effect on male bodies and masculinizing effects on female bodies.
  • Lidocaine, benzocaine and other numbing agents – These are a godsend for rashes because they numb that itchy feeling. But numbing lubes prevent bottoms from listening to your body, which can lead to tissue damage or pain when they wear off.
  • Propylene glycol – A common ingredient in food and cosmetics, but several scientific studies have shown it can cause skin and allergic reactions, including contact dermatitis.
  • Petrolatum and petroleum-based oils – These increase the risk of bacterial infections in your ass and “take a long time to clear from your body” (translation: surprise diarrhea!) .

The four main types of lube

All personal lubricants are one of these four types.

Water-based lubricants

Water-based lube is the most widely used. It’s also the most versatile, since it’s compatible with every kind of condom and toy. One downside: it can dry out really fast. And bad ones can leave a sticky film or turn into “lube boogers” after drying. But the main ingredient–water or aloe–makes it the easiest to clean. And it doesn’t stain sheets.

Compatible with: All types of condoms and all types of sex toys

Incompatible with: Nothing

Downsides: Dries quickly, can turn into little “lube boogers” after drying

Silicone-based lubricants

Silicone lube are much slicker than water-based ones. Also, they stay wet much longer, requiring less frequent reapplication, since silicone molecules aren’t absorbed by skin.. Silicone lube gets along great with latex condoms, but should not be used with silicone toys since it degrades them.

But when sexy times are finished, silicone lubes can take some scrubbing to wash off. That very same quality makes them perfect for having sex in the pool and shower.

Compatible with: Latex condoms, sex toys made from most non-porous materials (stainless steel, glass, wood, ceramic, hard plastic)

Incompatible with: Silicone toys

Downsides: Can take some scrubbing to completely wash off, some brands can stain bedding

Oil-based lubricants

Oil-based lube feels great. It’s wonderful for anal sex since it melts with body heat. But it creates microscopic holes in latex condoms, so it’s best for monogamous couples or people you trust.

Quality oil-based lubes can be hard to find on store shelves, so if you’re in a pinch, grab any pure plant-based oils you if you have one around the house. Coconut oil and shea butter are fantastic for butt play of all kinds.

Furthermore, oil-based lubes are great moisturizers since they nourish your hair, skin, and nails.

But, and this is a big but, you should only use oil lubes made from organic, unprocessed plant-based oils.

Low-quality oil lubes made with petroleum will ruin sex toys if they’re made from silicone or porous materials such as TPE, PVC, or cyberskin. 

Sadly, some oil-based lubes can leave dark spots on sheets. If you’re worried about that, do a patch test or just use with old sheets.

Compatible with: Hard, non-porous sex toys and silicone sex toys (if lube is pure plant-based oil)

Incompatible with: Latex condoms and sex toys made from non-porous materials like TPE and PVC

Downsides: Some can leave stains on sheets and leave you feeling greasy

Hybrid lubricants

Hybrid lubes are slicker and longer-lasting than simple water-based lubes since they’re made from a blend of silicone and water. And just like with water-based lubes, hybrids can be used with latex condoms and all your sex–even your silicone toys. 

Compatible with: All types of condoms and all types of sex toys

Incompatible with: Nothing

Downsides: Dry out faster than silicone and oil-based lubes

Sliquid Silk hybrid
Photo: Harry D. Somers
This all-natural hybrid lube is thick, long-lasting and slippery. It’s easy to wash off with just water, affordable, and never stains sheets.

Product Specs

Ingredients

Purified water, plant cellulose (from cotton), isopropyl palmitate, polysorbate 20, dimethicone, emollient ester, potassium sorbate, citric acid

Available sizes

2oz, 4.2 oz, 8.5 oz, .17 oz pillow (10-pack)

Photo: Harry D. Somers
Photo: Harry D. Somers
This silicone lube feels super-slick, stays wet, and never gets sticky. It moisturizes your skin with vitamin E and aloe, and it’s stain-free. However, it takes a little scrubbing with soap and water to wash off completely.

Product Specs

Ingredients

Cyclopentasilicone, dimethicone, dimethiconol, tocopherol acetate (vitamin E), aloe barbadensis leaf extract

Available sizes

2 oz, 4 oz,16 oz, 32 oz

Photo: Harry D. Somers
Photo: Harry D. Somers
This popular all-natural, glycerin-free, paraben-free lube was formulated specifically for anal sex. It has a thicker, sloppier consistency that stays wet longer than other water-based lubes.

Product Specs

Ingredients

Dimethicone, cyclopentasiloxane, dimethiconol, simmondsia chinensis (jojoba) seed oil, amyris balsamifera bark oil

Available sizes

3.4 oz / 100 ml, 8.5 oz / 250 ml

Pjur Analyse Me silicone lubricant
Photo: Harry D. Somers
This ultra-concentrated, long-lasting silicone lube offers a unique-yet-effective alternative to desensitizing lubes. Instead of numbing the butt, it relaxes tight butt muscles resulting in pain-free anal sex.

Product Specs

Ingredients

Dimethicone, cyclopentasiloxane, dimethiconol, simmondsia chinensis (jojoba) seed oil, amyris balsamifera bark oil

Available sizes

3.4 oz / 100 ml, 8.5 oz / 250 ml

The Butters oil-based lubricant
Photo: Harry D. Somers
This plant-based cream lube is great for anal and vaginal sex, but can also be used as a massage oil and moisturizer. It feels smooth, but not greasy. It’s non-staining, available in a range of sizes, and very affordable.

Product Specs

Ingredients

Aloe vera gel, raw shea butter, pure coconut oil, pure extra virgin olive oil, pure grapeseed oil, pure palm kernel oil, pure soy lipid emulsion, apple cider vinegar, guar bean powder, potassium sorbate

Available sizes

.25 oz, 2oz, 4.1oz, 8.2 oz

Alternatives to consider

We recommend Sliquid Organics Natural Gel if you only put organic things in your body or have had a negative reaction to Sliquid Sassy or The Butters. In our research, we were unable to find anyone who had a bad reaction to Sliquid Organics Natural Gel. It’s made from 95% organic, plant-based ingredients and retains its slickness for a long time. However, it is about twice as thick as Sliquid Sassy, so if you don’t like thick lubes, you may not like it.
Swiss Navy Premium Silicone is a popular silicone lube for butt play because it provides frictionless, long-lasting lubrication. Testers noted that it’s slippery gliding feel was virtually identical to Gun Oil, and they liked that it contains tocopherol acetate (vitamin E) because it left their skin feeling supple. However, one tester felt it was even harder to wash off the skin. And since Swiss Navy Premium tends to cost a few dollars more than Gun Oil, we don’t think it merits a recommendation. However, it is a good anal lube if you can find it on sale.
Viva Naturals Organic Extra Virgin Coconut Oil is made from 100% pure, organic, cold-pressed coconut oil. It has an army of Amazon fans who use it for cooking and baking as well as a single-ingredient lube, body lotion, and hair conditioner. It works great with toys made from 100% silicone and porous materials, but it can’t be used with condoms and can leave stains on your sheets. If you want to see what all the fuss is about with oil-based lubes and don’t care about those limitations, this is the most economical option and comes in a range of bulk sizes.

Pjur Back Door Silicone is another outstanding silicone-based anal sex lubricant from the German company that manufactures our fourth pick, Pjur Analyse Me Silicone. Coming from the same company and sharing similar-sounding names, we might expect these silicone-based lubes to be slight variations of each other. Both contain jojoba to help relax tight ass muscles and leave it feeling more supple. But the similarities end there.

Pjur developed Back Door “for intensive anal sex”, not nervous beginners who need help making anal less uncomfortable and painful. Thus, the high-grade silicones in Back Door are dosed at higher concentrations than the ones in Analyse Me. This means that Back Door lasts much longer than Analyse Me, making it perfect for marathon ass fucking sessions. Also, Back Door lacks amyris balsamifera, a second plant extract that relaxes tight ass muscles. The jojoba in Back Door does give it a noticeable relaxing effect “down there”, but it’s not as noticeable as Analyse Me. We loved how Pjur Back Door transmits your partner’s body heat and allows you to feel more of their genital contours. If you are dealing with a super-tight butthole, Analyse Me is still your best bet. But if you’re looking for an ultra-long lasting silicone lube for five hour sex sessions and want to save some money, we recommend Back Door since it’s usually a few bucks cheaper.

We thought Wicked Sensual Water-Based was an excellent lube for anal. Testers liked that it contains aloe and olive leaf extract and its slick, thick, gel-like consistency a lot, as well as its ability to stay wet longer than other water lubes. One tester noted that it was so similar to Sliquid Sassy that he couldn’t tell the two apart when his eyes were closed–a compliment since we thought Sassy was the best-of-the-best among water-based lubes. Its black packaging was even more stylish than the bright pink label on Sassy.

But compared to Sassy, Wicked Sensual Water-Based has a longer list of ingredients with chemical-sounding names and a higher price tag. We think Wicked is a top notch lube–especially for people who leave lube on their nightstands who aren’t sticklers about each and every ingredient.

Harry D. Somers

Harry D. Somers

Hey I'm Harry, one of the guys behind Fresh Materials.

Leave a Comment